All reviews shown are from real guest experiences. Only travellers who have booked a stay with us can submit a review. We verify reviews according to our guidelines and publish all reviews, positive or negative.More informationOpens in a new window
This was the worse place I’ve ever stayed it was completely dirty it smelled so bad!! There is no where to eat on site. And the men who checked us in was so scary I made my husband check us in there were wearing hoodies and mask just felt off!! And then they were doing work in the room next to us until 1 am using drills moving furniture we didn’t any sleep I would rather slept in my car!! Never come here!!
Staff was really great! Location was awesome. I wouldn’t exactly say rooms were resort style - more like super 8.
Booked with intentions of hanging out poolside. It appeared they were in the process of remodeling the pool because it was closed. Right next door is the Islander which offers a public pool. Neither the Commodore’s pool or the Islander’s pool was open
Property was insanely dirty and a dark alley with no lights. Did not seem safe at night. Ran out of toilet paper and the front desk person didn’t even know where it was kept. Do not stay here!!!
Our stay was okay. Nothing to really brag about. The room could’ve been cleaned better but it was okay. For the price, you get what you pay for.
Shanell
Stayed 2 nights in Sep 2024
6/10 Okay
Mark
Travelled with family
8 Sept 2024
Disliked: Property conditions & facilities
Noisy
Mark
Stayed 2 nights in Sep 2024
6/10 Okay
Mike
3 Sept 2024
Liked: Cleanliness, staff & service, room comfort
Disliked: Property conditions & facilities
Surprisingly decent!
Got to say I was surprised about this hotel. It's definitely one of the budget friendly hotels on island. Don't expect too much from it. The location was outstanding. Right on the middle of all the fun. Located next to two pool bars. A subway open late located in the lobby. The hotel is old and run down in parts, however, we did feel it was clean and never thought negatively about it. Just understand it's a budget place. If your comfortable with the minimum and looking for primarily a crash pad. I recommend it.
Had just bare necessities nothing extra no elevators and way way over priced for what u get wouldn’t recommend it
Mark
Stayed 2 nights in Jul 2024
4/10 Poor
Paul
13 Aug 2024
Disliked: Property conditions & facilities
The pool is the best part of the Commodore, yet it doesn’t work well for swimming or sunning. The pool is for standing in to cool off while drinking. The room was small and cheaply furnished. Morning free coffee was weak. There’s no place to sit down with friends to talk or play a game. It is a difficult motel to find.
The worst place I ever stayed. I booked 2 nights but only stayed one because I just could not take the disgusting room I would never recommend this dump
It’s a great location but man it was dirty. Lots of hair on the floor from previous guests, smears of some questionable origin all across the tv, stains on sheets and blankets, bathroom sink was clogged. WAY too expensive for this level of filth.
Location was great. The young front desk girls were on their phone while you stood at the desk and ignored you. Smoking was allowed all through the pool. Just gross
Tina
Stayed 2 nights in Jul 2024
2/10 Terrible
Kelly
Travelled with family
24 Jul 2024
The room was gross! When I pulled the cloth blind it was filthy dirty!
I had to wipe the top of the bed had black dirt on top.
Then the best is that I paid a “resort “ fee for what ? This was a room that entered as a motel. There was a pool but it was a public pool! All these people that stayed else where that Intalked to were using this pool but I paid a “resort “ fee! Never stay here !!