Important things were fine: WiFi, comfortable bed (just the two of us and we only used the king bed), heat/AC, appliances. The living room chairs are extremely comfortable. But the house is old and needs more attention; just one example - the door knob on the bathroom door was extremely loose.
It would be nice to have more supplies. The only coffee maker was the type where you make a pot with coffee in a filter. That's okay, except there was no coffee, no sweeteners (sugar or no-cal), no creamer or milk. We had K-cups with us since those machines are more common, but no loose coffee for this machine. There were no extra rolls of toilet paper, no tissues. And even though the instructions told us where to find a few things (such as ziplock bags and saran wrap), there wasn't any.
The house was clean, but smelled of cleaners and was stuffy. So I wanted to open a few windows. No windows can be opened to let in fresh air! Instead of a screen, the windows have a second glass window.
Summary - the most important things were fine, but more attention to minor repairs and providing more supplies would raise my rating to a 5.